We’re up for another round of The Kosher Connection Link up thingamabob, and with Rosh Hashana right around the corner, this months theme is apples. So ever since I was a little kid I can remember my grandmother making this thing we all called apple cake. For some reason, I never really questioned the idea of how this became known as “apple cake,” as you’ll soon see. Well this apple cake really was always made for Sukkos, and my grandmother had this special sheet pan that she used for it, in fact I think it’s the only thing she made in the pan. Anyway, suffice it to say that it was awesome. It would sit behind my kitchen table, half covered in aluminum foil, but really anyone who passed it, for some reason, had this innate need to just even out the edges. You know – a little slice off the edge to make sure the edge was even…all in the name of science. Last year I decided it was time for me to try and make this “cake.”
The reason I call this a “cake” is because it’s really more like a pie than a cake. There’s whole apples, mixed with spices, sandwiched between two enriched doughs. Sounds like a pie to me, but for some reason, it’s always been known as apple cake in our house
So last year I ventured out to make it, and got the recipe from my grandmother through my sister in law, which means my grandmother probably left something out, so we wouldn’t make it as well as she does. (I once asked my grandmother for her recipe for meatballs, and she pretty much just told me to throw a can of tomato sauce in a pot with the formed meatballs…after I did that with unwavering faith, and the meatballs were terrible, I asked her, and she was like “well what about the ketchup, sugar, and more water? Of course you have to put that in also!”) Getting a recipe from my grandmother is like playing broken telephone with some one speaks broken english and can’t hear that well. It’s not always easy. Here’s what I ended up with:
First thing is to make the dough. I said it was with enriched dough, and by that I mean there’s added fat. In general, you can categorize doughs as just plain old flour, water, yeast, and salt; or you can enrich said dough with different types of fats. This enrichment, obviously effects the taste, but it also preserves the dough, and effects the texture of the dough. You can see the difference when you compare homemade bread (without any added fats), and homemade kokosh, or cinnamon buns. There’s an inherent richness to the dough, but the dough will also be fluffier, and actually last longer. (I say homemade dough, as opposed to store bought dough, because all store bought bread will have different preservatives in it…it’s not natural for a loaf of bread to last more than 3 days). There’s also eggs in the form of yolks, which also add richness, along with color, and other properties that I’m not in the mood of getting in to (read: I’m not really sure, and not in the mood of doing the research).
Allright, let’s get some margarine a-melting. About 1 pound of fat, which is 4 sticks of margarine/butter. Once the melted margarine is cool, whisk in the eggs. Set aside, and work on the rest of the dough. Add the flour and sugar, and whisk together, and combine remaining sugar, yeast, and tepid water, and whisk to combine. Add yeast mixture and fatty fat fat mixture to the flour, and using the paddle attachment (or a wooden spoon) to mix until it just comes together, and then switch to a dough hook, and knead until it pulls away from the bowl, and a tacky, but not sticky dough forms. Allow that dough to rest in the fridge over night (or up to 3 days).
On the day you’re ready to make your apple cake, allow the dough to come to room temperature for at least an hour. While the dough is coming to terms with it’s surrounding, make the filling. My grandmaw’s recipe calls for 10 apples, 1/2 cup of sugar, cinnamon, vanilla, and lemon juice. You shred the apples, and wring out any excess liquid, and then mix everything together.
You then roll out half the dough, put it on bottom of the sheet pan, place the apple mixture in (leaving about a half inch around the borders) cover with other dough, and crimp the whole thing shut. Brush some egg over top, and let it bake until golden brown and delicious.
So I actually made this last year for Sukkos, and luckily was able to dig through the archives of all the food I take pictures of (it’s a lot…like, I take pictures of everything, and then I’m too self conscience to post anything about it…but I’ll just save that last part for the couch…aaaanyway…), and if I could critique it, I would say, I would treat this “cake” more like a pie, and would definitely add some sort of thickening agent; flour, corn starch, potato starch, tapioca, whatever. Also, I would consider mixing the apples with sugar, allowing it macerate, and then taking the liquid, and cooking it down and adding that concentrated apple flavor back in. Those are the modifications I’ll probably do this year.
As usual, click on the funny frog looking guy right below this paragraph to see what actual talented people did.
Bobby’s Apple Cake
I know that when I made this last year, I ended up with two whole apple cakes, but I can’t remember if that was because I doubled the recipe. So if you see that there’s a lot of dough, then instead of using half to line the sheet pan, use 1/4…knowwhatimsaying?
For the Dough:
- 5 cups flour
- 1 cup sugar, divided
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 2 teaspoons yeast
- 1/2 cup tepid water
- 4 sticks margarine
- 4 yolks
- 1 whole egg
For the Apple filling:
- 10 apples (I like to use a mixture of yellow, green, and another apple, to get a good mix of texture and flavor out of the apples), shredded
- 1/2 cup sugar
- 2 teaspoons fresh lemon juice
- 2 tablespoons corn starch
- 1/4 teaspoon cinnamon
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1 egg
For the Dough:
- Combine flour, and 1/2 cup sugar in a bowl, and whisk to combine. Combine the vanilla extract, remaining 1/2 cup sugar, yeast, and water in a bowl, and stir to combine until frothy.
- Melt the margarine, and when cool, add the yolks and egg, and whisk to combine.
- Add the flour mixture, the yeast mixture, and margarine mixture to bowl of a mixer, and with the paddle attachment, mix until everything is combined. Switch to the dough hook, and knead on medium-low until dough pulls away from the sides of the bowl.
- Place dough in an oiled container, cover, and place in the refrigerator over night and up to 3 nights
- On the day of baking, allow the dough to come to room temperature for at least an hour before handling.
For the filling:
- To shred apples, peel and core the apples, and run through food processor’s shredding blade.
- Combine apples, sugar, and lemon juice, and let sit over colander set in a bowl for at least 30 minutes.
- Take reserved apple juice, and set in a pan over medium-high heat and reduce liquid until syrupy.
- Add syrup back to apple-sugar mixture, along with corn starch, cinnamon, and vanilla extract, and mix to combine.
- Divide dough in half, and roll out half the dough, and spread on baking sheet lined with aluminum foil.
- Spread apple mixture over bottom half of dough, leaving a 1/2 inch space around the borders
- Roll out other half, and cover everything cinching it all closed.
- Whisk remaining egg, and brush over dough
- Bake in preheated 350 degree oven until golden brown and delicious (I can’t remember how long it took, but if I had to guess, it was probably 30 minutes? I dunno, let your nose decide)
14 thoughts on “Bobby’s Apple Cake”
I love that you have gotten your grandmother’s recipe down for posterity. I love this kind of apple “cake.” I usually see recipes that call for two layers of cookie dough around the apple filling and I like the idea of using yeast dough instead.
BTW, I have an idea for solving the excess moisture issue. My great grandmother’s strudel also calls for shredded apples, but, between us, the strudel filling is better if you use cooked apple slices, preferably golden delicious, which hold their shape nicely after cooking and don’t go all mushy. If you reduce down the apple juices until they get thick, no cornstarch needed! And, if you caramelize the sugar, noch besser.
Yeah my grandmother only uses golden delicious apples…personally I like to use different types of apples for flavor, but now you got me wondering if I only used golden delicious or even better if I used green apples which hold their shapes even better, what would be the end result…I see experimentation in my future
Oooh, my Aunt Beck made a similar apple cake every year and used to argue with my mother (her sister) about whether her apple cake or my mom’s pie was better. I like that you used yeast dough.
Thanks… Did they also call it apple cake?
you forgot the fork marks.
True…maybe that’s why it wasn’t as good
I am glad to see you left out the traif lettuce
Ha…yup, wasn’t sure it would go well
I am going to go out on a limb here and ask a question that may get me banned from ever posting again on this blog:
Have you tried this with canned apples?
If it wasn’t the Phoenix Fresser, I might just banish you to eternal spam-dom, but being the fact that you’re probably the most popular person on this blog, I’ll let this one slide on account that you’re very busy, and need to find a way to make this with your hectic life…so lemme answer it this way – would you eat canned apple pie filling with out anything else? Ie straight from the can? If the answer is yes (and there’s nothing wrong that, I don’t judge), then by all means…I personally wouldn’t, so there’s no reason slapping some dough on top of it should change what I want to eat
(the same goes true for anything for that matter….tomato sauce? Don Pepinno’s? Yuck!! Know what I’m saying?)
Thanks for the free pass. 🙂
I can only imagine how buttery and delicious this is! Nice family recipe 🙂
One of my favorite shows growing up was Bobby’s world